SocProf a publié une critique de The Chaos Machine par Max Fisher
The problem with social media platforms is social media platforms
5 étoiles
That is the main thesis of the book: that the algorithms deployed by giants like Facebook, Youtube, and Twitter do not just allow like-minded people to find each other but that they actively push people together into extremist bubbles through their recommendation engines, up to and including genocide (as in Myanmar and Sri Lanka). The book goes through what seems to be considered now the origin story of radicalization and harassment via social media: gamergate. Things got worse from there, all the way to the January 6th attempted coup. The throughline is how social media platforms algorithmically push people towards extremism and outrage (which is more likely to be found on the right... see Irony and Outrage on this) because outrage keeps people glued to the platforms. The platforms want people on as much as possible, and if the way to get it is to destroy democracy, spread disinformation, destroy …
That is the main thesis of the book: that the algorithms deployed by giants like Facebook, Youtube, and Twitter do not just allow like-minded people to find each other but that they actively push people together into extremist bubbles through their recommendation engines, up to and including genocide (as in Myanmar and Sri Lanka). The book goes through what seems to be considered now the origin story of radicalization and harassment via social media: gamergate. Things got worse from there, all the way to the January 6th attempted coup. The throughline is how social media platforms algorithmically push people towards extremism and outrage (which is more likely to be found on the right... see Irony and Outrage on this) because outrage keeps people glued to the platforms. The platforms want people on as much as possible, and if the way to get it is to destroy democracy, spread disinformation, destroy any chance at public health, and violence, then so be it. Throughout the book, Fisher shows how the platform leaders knew the impact of their algorithm and did nothing, as one extremist event unfolded after another, rooted on the platforms, and yet they did nothing because the business model demands this. So it is not simply extremists finding each other actively on social media, it is social media pushing not just extremists but regular people into extremists groups or channels for the sake attention and data. It is deeply depressing and yet important. And because the platforms have learned nothing (and rolled back some of the measures they reluctantly took in 2020), we can expect more as the 2024 US presidential election approaches. All the more reasons to get off these platforms.
